13. Nomar Garciaparra
13. "After the 2000 season, Garciaparra was never the same. The rest of his career was ravaged by injuries. If he could have stayed healthy, who knows what he could have become, but even though he only had those four successful years, he is still looked at as one of the premier shortstops we have seen. For that reason, Nomar is overrated. " - McPartlin.
Team: Oakland Atheletics, Positions: Shortstop, First Baseman and Third Baseman, Ending Salary:$78.5M (credit: By STEPHEN DUNN/Getty Images)